Publication Ethics and Research Integrity Policy

The Editorial Team of Revista de Derecho de la Universidad Católica de la Santísima Concepción  is committed to upholding the highest standards of publication ethics, research integrity, transparency, and editorial quality.

To this end, the Journal follows the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the Singapore Statement on Research Integrity, and internationally recognized guidance on ethical scholarly publishing.

These commitments are reflected in the following provisions, which apply to authors, reviewers, editors, and all individuals involved in the editorial process.

Responsibilities of the Editor-in-Chief and the Co-Editor

The Editor-in-Chief and the Co-Editor are responsible for the overall management of the editorial process and for safeguarding the Journal's academic quality, integrity, and relevance.

Within this framework, they are responsible for ensuring compliance with editorial policies and publication ethics, making certain that all manuscripts are evaluated according to academic, scientific, and ethical criteria. They are also responsible for making final decisions regarding the acceptance, rejection, or revision of articles, based on peer review reports and the academic merit of each submission.

Likewise, they must ensure transparency, impartiality, and confidentiality throughout the editorial process, as well as the appropriate management of conflicts of interest, complaints, and potential misconduct, in accordance with international standards. Their responsibilities also include promoting the Journal's continuous improvement, visibility, and internationalization, as well as compliance with the requirements established by scholarly indexing systems.

Responsibilities of the Editorial Team

Evaluation and peer review: The Editorial Team shall ensure the selection of qualified reviewers with expertise relevant to the subject matter of each manuscript, promoting a rigorous, objective, and timely evaluation process.

Impartiality and fairness: Editorial decisions shall be based exclusively on the academic and scientific merit of manuscripts, without discrimination on the grounds of gender, sexual orientation, beliefs, ethnic origin, institutional affiliation, or nationality of the authors.

Management of ethical concerns: The Editorial Team shall establish clear and transparent procedures for addressing potential ethical concerns, complaints, or grievances, guaranteeing authors the right to respond and ensuring that each case is properly investigated.

Confidentiality: The Editorial Team is committed to maintaining the confidentiality of manuscripts at every stage of the editorial process, as well as protecting the identities of authors and reviewers, in accordance with the peer review system adopted by Revista de Derecho de la Universidad Católica de la Santísima Concepción.

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Contribution to editorial quality: Reviewers support editorial decision-making through critical, objective, and well-founded assessments, contributing to the improvement of the scientific quality of manuscripts.

Confidentiality: All information contained in manuscripts must be treated as confidential and must not be used for personal or professional purposes.

Identification of irregularities: Reviewers must inform the Editorial Team of any suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, or substantial similarity to other works.

Conflicts of interest: as set out in the Conflict of Interest Policy.

Responsibilities of Authors

References and sources: Authors must ensure the accurate citation of all bibliographic and documentary sources used, in accordance with the editorial guidelines of Revista de Derecho de la Universidad Católica de la Santísima Concepción, guaranteeing the traceability and reliability of the information presented.

Funding sources: All sources of funding, whether public or private, must be explicitly disclosed, identifying the sponsoring institution and, where applicable, the associated project or grant number.

Authorship and responsibility: Authors assume responsibility for the content of their manuscripts and guarantee that the data presented are truthful and authentic. They must also ensure that all listed authors have made significant contributions to the research and have approved the final submitted version.

Data availability: Authors must maintain accurate records of the data used in their research and, when requested, provide the Editorial Team with access to such data, while safeguarding ethical requirements and confidentiality.

Ethical considerations in research: In studies involving human participants, authors must ensure compliance with research ethics principles, including informed consent, participant confidentiality, and, where applicable, approval by an institutional research ethics committee.

Conflicts of interest: as set out in the Conflict of Interest Policy.

Ethical Oversight

The Editorial Team of Revista de Derecho de la Universidad Católica de la Santísima Concepción shall request information from authors regarding the ethical standards applied in their research, which must comply with the principles established in the Singapore Statement on Research Integrity.

Where applicable, authors must describe the ethical procedures followed during their research and, upon request from editors or reviewers, provide relevant information concerning the ethical safeguards implemented, particularly in matters involving consent or assent, or authorization for the collection and use of data and information.

The use of photographs depicting identifiable individuals must be supported by appropriate authorization and must not cause harm to the persons appearing in the images.

I. Plagiarism and Originality

The Journal considers plagiarism a serious breach of academic and research integrity. Accordingly, all manuscripts submitted for consideration must be original, unpublished, and respectful of third-party intellectual property rights.

Authors must ensure that their submissions constitute their own scholarly contributions and that all sources have been properly acknowledged and cited.

Practices contrary to research integrity include, but are not limited to, reproducing third-party texts without attribution, misappropriating the ideas or findings of other researchers, paraphrasing without acknowledging the original source, and using protected materials without the necessary authorization.

Originality checks are carried out under the Similarity Policy.

Where indications of plagiarism arise, the relevant information and explanations will be requested before a final decision is made.

Confirmed violations may result in rejection or, where the article has already been published, appropriate editorial action, including corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions, depending on the seriousness of the case.

The Journal preserves the traceability of its decisions and ensures a documented, impartial procedure that respects the right to respond.

Authors are responsible for ensuring that tables, figures, photographs, graphs, and other materials included in their manuscripts do not infringe third-party rights.

Authors must also submit the originality declaration and the copyright and publication authorization documents required by the Journal.

II. Research Fraud

The Journal publishes legal research that must comply with the principles of honesty, methodological rigor, transparency, and scholarly responsibility.

Authors must accurately report the methods employed, sources examined, findings obtained, and conclusions reached.

Research fraud or misconduct includes, but is not limited to:

  1. Fabrication or falsification of data, findings, documents, or sources.
  2. Deliberate manipulation of information to support predetermined conclusions.
  3. Use of nonexistent or deliberately inaccurate bibliographic references.
  4. Misrepresentation of judicial decisions, legal provisions, or scholarly documents.
  5. Intentional omission of relevant information that substantially alters research findings.
  6. Improper citation manipulation intended to advance personal, institutional, or editorial interests.

Authors must retain the supporting materials necessary to reasonably verify their claims and, where appropriate, make them available to the Editorial Team during peer review or an ethics investigation.

In legal research, this responsibility particularly concerns the verifiable identification of legislative, judicial, doctrinal, documentary, and empirical sources.

Confirmed serious misconduct may justify rejection or appropriate post-publication measures.

III. Duplicate Publication and Simultaneous Submission

Manuscripts submitted to the Journal must be original and unpublished and must not be under consideration by another scholarly publication at the same time.

Authors must expressly declare that their work has not been previously published and is not undergoing another editorial evaluation process.

Previous publication of the same article in another language does not constitute an original unpublished contribution and will therefore not be accepted as an original publication.

Legitimate use of previous research must be accompanied by appropriate citations and bibliographic references clearly identifying earlier contributions.

Prior dissemination as a preprint is governed by the Preprints Policy.

Authors must disclose any circumstances that may affect the originality or exclusivity of their submission.

Where simultaneous submission or improper duplicate publication is identified, the Editorial Team will examine the relevant circumstances and may reject the manuscript after communicating with the authors.

IV. Inappropriate Fragmentation of Research

The Journal considers the artificial fragmentation of a research project into multiple publications contrary to good scholarly practice when such division lacks academic justification and is intended primarily to multiply publication outputs.

This practice, commonly known as salami slicing, may undermine transparency, originality, and the proper interpretation of research findings.

Multiple articles arising from the same research project may be considered where each presents a sufficiently distinct research question, methodology, analysis, or scholarly contribution.

In such cases, authors must:

  1. Identify and cite related previous publications.
  2. Explain the specific contribution of the new manuscript.
  3. Avoid unnecessary reproduction of previously published material.
  4. Inform the Editorial Team of closely related works.
  5. Provide supporting information when requested to verify the originality of the contribution.

Thematic overlap between publications does not, in itself, constitute misconduct. The assessment focuses on whether the manuscript makes an independent and sufficiently justified scholarly contribution.

Where inappropriate fragmentation is identified, the Editorial Team may request clarification or revisions, or reject the manuscript through a reasoned decision.

V. Complaints and Appeals

Complaints and appeals must be sent, with their grounds, to revistadederecho@ucsc.cl. The Editor-in-Chief acknowledges receipt, hears those involved, and decides in writing within a reasonable time, impartially and confidentially, in line with COPE recommendations. An appeal against an editorial decision must rest on academic or procedural grounds; disagreement with a review is not enough on its own. Anyone with a conflict of interest, including the Editor-in-Chief, withdraws, and the case is decided by another member of the Editorial Team.

Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions are governed by the Correction Policy.

VI. Institutional Commitment to Research Integrity

The Journal promotes an editorial culture grounded in academic honesty, independent decision-making, procedural transparency, and respect for the rights of authors, reviewers, and readers.

Proceedings concerning potential ethical violations are conducted according to the principles of objectivity, confidentiality, proportionality, and procedural fairness.

The Journal may refer matters to the competent institutional authorities where warranted by the nature or seriousness of the circumstances.

The Editorial Team periodically reviews this policy to ensure its continued consistency with international recommendations on publication ethics and research integrity and applicable institutional regulations.